WoW: Forever Blackmaw Hold Gold Farm Backlash Hits #1 on r/all

Here is why WoW: Forever players are angry about the Blackmaw Hold gold farm, what they want Blizzard to do, and what Blizzard has said about the economy.

NewsGameLeap Team

WoW: Forever artwork
Blizzard Entertainment, Zsastrasza

WoW: Forever was sold as a fresh start where nobody has to rush, but a gold farm in Blackmaw Hold has put that promise under strain. According to Wowhead, the farm pumped thousands of gold into the brand-new economy before it was fixed, and the fallout has taken over the WoW subreddits, with a petition about the players who used it reaching the top of r/all.

The anger isn't only about who got rich. It's about what a pile of early gold does to an economy where most players are still leveling, and about whether Blizzard will step in. Below we go through what happened, how the community has reacted and what Blizzard has said about the economy so far, based on Wowhead's report.

What Happened in Blackmaw Hold

You need to be level 55 or higher to enter Blackmaw Hold, so most of the player base never saw the farm first-hand. That doesn't mean they'll escape its effects. Wowhead's worry is twofold. Players sitting on that much gold can corner a market, buying up every Arcane Crystal for example. And a general jump in the gold supply pushes prices up on everything while the majority of players are still on the road to the cap.

It also cuts against the pitch. In an interview with MMORPG, the team described WoW: Forever as "giving you permission to take your time", the same philosophy behind its stance on dungeon quests that take more than one run. Players who took that advice now feel they were punished for it, and that they should have rushed after all.

The Community Reaction

Across r/wow, r/wowforever and r/classicwow, Wowhead says nearly every post on the front pages is about the farm and its impact, with plenty of players asking Blizzard to do something. The loudest signal came when a petition to ban popular streamers who allegedly abused the farm climbed to the number-one spot on r/all, which Wowhead captured at 7:55 AM PST.

A lot of the discussion leans on an old World of Warcraft saying: "Exploit Early, Exploit Often". It describes the pattern where a bug or unintended strategy hands out an advantage, gets patched, and nobody who used it faces consequences. Everyone who missed out ends up feeling behind, and that feeling is a poor fit for a version built around the trip to 60 rather than the finish line.

What Blizzard Has Said

At the time of Wowhead's report, the open question was what Blizzard would do about the farm. The team has spoken about the economy recently, though. In a But Why Tho? interview, it said it's paying closer attention to the economy than ever before and wants to enforce fair play where possible. It also said it's taking a much stronger stance on rule-breaking that affects the economy, especially given how large it expects economies to become on its real estate architecture.

Wowhead's point is that this is the first real test of that stance. Do nothing, and players learn that exploiting early pays. Take action, and they learn to report an unintended strategy and leave it be, because the gains won't stick. Either way, the answer sets the precedent for everything that follows in WoW: Forever.

If you'd rather build your gold the slow way, our professions and gold making guide covers the routes that won't get patched, and the dungeon list by level shows when Blackmaw Hold and the rest open up for you. For the latest fixes, see the November 16 hotfixes.

More in World of Warcraft

All World of Warcraft